Private Internet Access (PIA) vs. NordVPN: A Comprehensive Comparison for 2024

In today's digital age, safeguarding your online privacy and security is more crucial than ever. Virtual Private Networks (VPNs) have emerged as essential tools, encrypting your internet connection and masking your IP address to protect against cyber threats and unauthorized surveillance.

Among the myriad of VPN services available, NordVPN and Private Internet Access (PIA) stand out as two of the most prominent providers. Both have garnered substantial user bases and offer a suite of features designed to enhance online security and privacy.

This article delves into a comprehensive comparison of Private Internet Access vs. NordVPN, examining their features, performance, pricing, and overall value. Our goal is to equip you with the insights needed to make an informed decision when selecting the VPN service that best aligns with your needs.

Company Backgrounds

Private Internet Access

Founded in 2010, Private Internet Access (PIA) is based in the United States. Despite operating in a country with extensive surveillance capabilities, PIA has maintained a strong stance on user privacy, implementing a strict no-logs policy that has been tested and proven in court. The company is renowned for its affordability, offering competitive pricing without compromising on security features. PIA provides robust security measures, including AES-256 encryption and various VPN protocols, catering to users seeking both cost-effectiveness and reliable protection.

NordVPN

Established in 2012, NordVPN has positioned itself as a leading player in the VPN industry. Headquartered in Panama, a jurisdiction known for its strong privacy laws, NordVPN benefits from an environment that supports its commitment to user confidentiality. The company has built a reputation for prioritizing privacy and security, offering features like AES-256 encryption, a strict no-logs policy, and advanced security protocols. These measures have earned NordVPN the trust of millions of users worldwide.

Security and Privacy Features

When evaluating VPN services, security and privacy are paramount. Both NordVPN and Private Internet Access (PIA) employ robust measures to protect user data and ensure anonymity online.

Encryption Standards

Both NordVPN and PIA utilize AES-256 encryption, widely regarded as the gold standard in data security. This level of encryption is virtually unbreakable, ensuring that user data remains confidential and secure from potential cyber threats.

No-Logs Policy

A strict no-logs policy is crucial for maintaining user privacy, as it ensures that the VPN provider does not record or store any information about user activities.

• NordVPN: NordVPN has undergone independent audits to verify its no-logs policy. These audits confirm that NordVPN does not track, collect, or share user data, reinforcing its commitment to user privacy.
• Private Internet Access (PIA): PIA's no-logs policy has been proven in court, demonstrating its dedication to user privacy. In multiple legal cases, PIA was unable to provide user data because it simply did not exist, underscoring its strict adherence to a no-logs policy.

Additional Security Features

Beyond encryption and no-logs policies, both VPNs offer additional features to enhance security and privacy:

NordVPN:

• Double VPN: This feature routes your traffic through two separate VPN servers, adding an extra layer of encryption and security.
• Onion Over VPN: Combining the benefits of NordVPN with the anonymity of the Onion network, this feature provides maximum privacy for users seeking enhanced anonymity.
• CyberSec: NordVPN's CyberSec feature blocks ads, trackers, and malicious websites, providing a safer and cleaner browsing experience.

Private Internet Access (PIA):

• MACE Ad Blocker: PIA's MACE feature blocks ads, trackers, and malware, enhancing user privacy and improving browsing speed.
• Port Forwarding: This feature allows users to redirect incoming connections to bypass NAT firewalls, which can be beneficial for activities like torrenting.

Server Network and Performance

When selecting a VPN, the size and distribution of its server network, along with its performance metrics, are crucial factors to consider.

Server Locations

• Private Internet Access (PIA): PIA offers a substantial network with servers in 91 countries, ensuring a wide range of connection options.

• NordVPN: As of October 2024, NordVPN boasts over 6,600 servers across 111 countries, providing users with extensive global coverage.

Speed Tests

Speed is a critical aspect of VPN performance, affecting activities like streaming, gaming, and browsing. Recent speed tests indicate that NordVPN consistently delivers high-speed connections, thanks to its NordLynx protocol, which is based on WireGuard technology. Users have reported minimal speed reductions when connected to NordVPN servers, making it suitable for bandwidth-intensive tasks.

PIA also utilizes the WireGuard protocol, offering competitive speeds. However, some users have noted occasional speed fluctuations, particularly when connecting to distant servers. Despite this, PIA generally provides reliable speeds for everyday use, including streaming and downloading.

Reliability and Uptime

Both NordVPN and PIA are recognized for their reliability and high uptime percentages. NordVPN maintains a robust infrastructure with a focus on server stability, resulting in minimal downtime. Users have reported consistent and uninterrupted connections, contributing to a positive user experience.

Similarly, PIA has invested in a next-generation server infrastructure, featuring RAM-only servers that enhance security and performance. This setup contributes to PIA's strong uptime record, ensuring users have access to stable connections.

In summary, both NordVPN and PIA offer extensive server networks with reliable performance. NordVPN's larger server count and consistently high speeds make it a strong contender for users seeking optimal performance. PIA provides a solid alternative with its wide coverage and dependable service, though users may experience occasional speed variations depending on server selection.

Streaming and Torrenting Capabilities

When evaluating VPN services, their effectiveness in accessing streaming platforms and supporting torrenting activities are crucial considerations.

Streaming Services Access

Both NordVPN and Private Internet Access (PIA) are designed to bypass geo-restrictions, enabling users to access content from various streaming platforms.

• Private Internet Access (PIA): PIA offers access to popular streaming services, including Netflix and Hulu. However, some users have encountered occasional challenges when attempting to access certain platforms like BBC iPlayer. While PIA continues to enhance its streaming capabilities, it may not be as reliable as NordVPN in this regard.

• NordVPN: Renowned for its robust streaming capabilities, NordVPN effectively unblocks major platforms such as Netflix, Hulu, and BBC iPlayer. Its SmartPlay technology combines VPN and Smart DNS features, ensuring seamless access to geo-restricted content. Users have reported consistent success in streaming high-definition content without buffering issues.

Torrenting Support

For users engaged in peer-to-peer (P2P) file sharing, both VPNs provide support, though their approaches differ.

• NordVPN: NordVPN offers specialized P2P servers optimized for torrenting activities. These servers are designed to provide fast and secure connections, ensuring user privacy during file sharing. Additionally, NordVPN's strict no-logs policy and advanced security features, such as a kill switch, further protect users during torrenting sessions.
• Private Internet Access (PIA): PIA supports P2P file sharing across its entire server network, allowing users the flexibility to choose any server for torrenting. The inclusion of port forwarding can enhance download speeds by connecting to more peers. PIA's commitment to user privacy, evidenced by its no-logs policy, ensures that torrenting activities remain confidential.

In summary, both NordVPN and PIA cater to users seeking streaming and torrenting capabilities. NordVPN stands out with its consistent ability to unblock a wide range of streaming platforms and offers specialized servers for torrenting. PIA provides comprehensive P2P support across all servers and includes features like port forwarding to enhance the torrenting experience. Users should consider their specific streaming and torrenting needs when choosing between these two VPN services.

User Interface and Ease of Use

A VPN's user interface (UI) and overall usability are crucial for ensuring a seamless experience across various devices. Both NordVPN and Private Internet Access (PIA) have developed applications and extensions tailored to different platforms, each with its unique design and features.

Desktop Applications

• Private Internet Access (PIA): PIA's desktop application offers a minimalist design with a focus on functionality. The main window displays connection status, selected server, and a prominent connect button. Users can access advanced settings, such as encryption levels, port forwarding, and DNS customization, through a more detailed menu. While the interface may appear less polished than NordVPN's, it provides a high degree of customization, appealing to advanced users.

• NordVPN: The desktop application boasts a clean and intuitive interface, featuring a world map for server selection and a sidebar for quick access to settings and specialized servers. Users can easily connect to the fastest server available or choose from a list of countries. The app includes features like Double VPN, Onion Over VPN, and a kill switch, all accessible with a few clicks. The settings menu is straightforward, allowing users to customize their experience without feeling overwhelmed.

Mobile Applications

• Private Internet Access (PIA): PIA's mobile applications mirror the minimalist design of their desktop counterpart. The main screen displays connection status and a connect button, with server selection accessible through a dropdown menu. Advanced settings, including encryption preferences and port forwarding, are available but may require more navigation compared to NordVPN's app. The app is functional and reliable, though it may lack some of the visual appeal found in NordVPN's design.
• NordVPN: The mobile apps for iOS and Android maintain the clean design of the desktop version, featuring a map-based interface and quick-connect options. Users can easily switch between servers, access specialty servers, and adjust settings like CyberSec and auto-connect. The app is responsive, with a user-friendly layout that caters to both novice and experienced users.

Browser Extensions

• Private Internet Access (PIA): Provides browser extensions for Chrome, Firefox, and Opera. These extensions offer features like WebRTC leak protection, third-party cookie blocking, and access to PIA's server network. The interface is straightforward, focusing on essential functionalities to enhance browser security and privacy.

• NordVPN: Offers browser extensions for Chrome, Firefox and Edge, providing quick access to VPN services without launching the full application. The extensions are user-friendly, allowing users to connect to servers, block WebRTC leaks, and enable CyberSec for ad blocking.They are particularly useful for securing browser traffic independently of other applications.

In summary, both NordVPN and PIA offer user-friendly applications and extensions across various platforms. NordVPN emphasizes a visually appealing and intuitive design, making it accessible for all user levels. PIA focuses on functionality and customization, catering to users who prefer a minimalist interface with advanced configuration options.

Pricing and Subscription Plans

When comparing VPN services, pricing and available features are also key considerations. Both NordVPN and Private Internet Access (PIA) offer tiered subscription plans with different pricing structures and features to meet a range of user needs.

NordVPN

NordVPN provides four primary subscription tiers: Basic, Plus, Complete, and Prime. Each plan offers increasing levels of security and additional features:

• Basic: Includes essential VPN features such as secure, high-speed VPN and Threat Protection, suitable for users needing standard privacy protection.
• Plus: Adds a password manager and data breach scanner, making it ideal for users wanting additional security layers.
• Complete: Includes all Plus features plus 1 TB of encrypted cloud storage, providing more comprehensive protection.
• Prime: Offers the full suite of NordVPN services, including Threat Protection Pro, advanced browsing protection, and ad/tracker blocking.

Private Internet Access (PIA)

PIA offers three main subscription plans, with straightforward pricing options:

• Monthly: Offers flexible, month-to-month pricing for those who prefer not to commit long-term.
• 1-Year Plan: Provides a discounted rate with annual billing.
• 3-Year Plan: Offers the most significant savings and is ideal for users seeking long-term protection at a low cost per month.

When comparing value for money, NordVPN offers more feature-rich plans, particularly in its Plus, Complete, and Prime tiers, which include tools like a password manager, data breach scanner, and secure cloud storage. This makes NordVPN a good option for users seeking comprehensive protection and added functionality.

On the other hand, PIA provides budget-friendly plans, especially with its 3-year plan, which is highly cost-effective for users who primarily need standard VPN features without extra services.

Ultimately, the choice between NordVPN and PIA will depend on your budget and whether you prioritize added features like cloud storage and advanced threat protection (NordVPN) or basic, reliable VPN service at a lower cost (PIA).

Conclusion

In this comprehensive comparison of Private Internet Access (PIA) and NordVPN, we've explored key aspects such as security features, server networks, performance, streaming capabilities, user interfaces, and pricing structures. Both VPNs offer robust security with AES-256 encryption and strict no-logs policies. NordVPN provides a larger server network and additional features like Double VPN and Onion Over VPN, while PIA offers affordability and essential functionalities.

• For Users Seeking Advanced Features: If you prioritize a wide server network, specialized security options, and additional tools like a password manager and encrypted cloud storage, NordVPN may be the better choice.
• For Budget-Conscious Users: If affordability and reliable core VPN services are your main concerns, PIA offers competitive pricing with essential features, making it a suitable option.

When choosing between NordVPN and PIA, assess your individual requirements, such as the importance of advanced security features, server availability in specific regions, streaming needs, and budget constraints. To experience these VPN services at a lower cost, consider using platforms like GoSplit, which allow users to share subscription costs, making premium VPN services more accessible.

By carefully evaluating your priorities and utilizing cost-sharing options, you can select the VPN service that best aligns with your needs and enhances your online security and privacy.